Asunto: Yellow Card Accumulation System

Greetings

I didnt understand one thing about yellow card accumulation system. Im Indonesia national team coach.

In Saturday, one of my national player, Jendri Barhan receive an accumulated yellow card penalty.

I thought he got that punishment at club level.

I have confirmed it and swear, a few minutes before the national team match, he did NOT receive a card accumulation penalty for the national team level. Only at club level. However, when the match started, his position was replaced by another player.

I don't know if there are other coaches who have experienced the same thing as me. But if there is, why could it happen like this??

If it was my negligence, that's no problem. But I need an explanation from the developer about this.

What exactly you don't understand?

He got 3 yellow cards in National Team so he was banned for one NT game.

There is a bug that shows the player's "card situation" for club level so you have to check it manually on list of NT players.

There is a bug that shows the player's "card situation" for club level so you have to check it manually on list of NT players.
Either, I do not understand what bug are You talking about, or You are talking about a bug which is already fixed, and for a long time, so can You elaborate what exactly situation are You talking about? or give me an example

If a player has a red card in club then in the NT lineup setting he is shown as "red" and unable to play, even though he can play.
It's not fixed because I had this situations in one of latest games.

And that's why this topic author's player seemed to be ok to play (it didn't show him as "red") even though he had three yellow/red card in NT.

To be exact

Gerald Maurer [37807715]
before my game Ireland - Deutschland he was shown as "red" and unable to play because he received a red card in a league game. So they did not fix this bug.

Ok, now I understand. Yes this bug is not fixed as no one who could do it was even aware of its existence, but even if devs were aware of it, it probably would not be fixed because it's related to the old view.

I thought You were talking about a bug showing player "card situation" from the club on new team page of NT.

I just question why a player who has accumulated yellow cards at club level can also have an impact on the national team.

If that's the rule, that's fine with me. But, what I regret is, why is there no information that this player cannot play in the national team. And it happened a few minutes before the game.

If it is a bug, I hope the bug can be fixed. I know this is not Sokker's official tournament. But this bug is quite disturbing Indonesia's journey in the Asian Cup.
(editado)

I just question why a player who has accumulated yellow cards at club level can also have an impact on the national team.

No, the count for club and National Teams are separate.
As an example check your player Bambang Fitriansyah. It shows 1 yellow card next to the player information. This is for official matches in the club.
If you see the NT section which is found below. It also shows a yellow card.
Please check manually in this way.



The bug they are talking about is the visual when setting the line up, which probably happened to you. Just check clicking the player what is the real state

He didn’t have a card accumulation at club level, he had 3 yellows at NT level.

He received his third yellow card in his last NT game against Guatemala and that’s why he was suspended for next NT game.

His last club yellow card was in February.
(editado)

I will see it

I think i will see it in ntdb, and check to synchronize.

I would love to know why yellow cards carry from one season to the next.

Doesn't happen in actual football as far as I know. NT possibly, but not league.

I would love to know why yellow cards carry from one season to the next.
to be a meaningful functionality probably, because if yellow cards would be reset after a season, the whole yellow card accumulation functionality would be pretty useless, it would almost never kick in

Because matches a season is fewer and the cards more rare
(editado)

yeah, this is a fair explanation.