Asunto: 3 Yellow card rule

Fine for each season, should be cleared to 0 cards each start of season, this must have been discussed many times before , is it that hard to do this? then why has it not been done in this overhaul?

definately

I think no. If we remove cards, injuries, randomness... this game would be really boring and predictable

I know about the difficulty of three yellow cards taking effect during the season in current system, but with the new league system there will be more fixtures so it would make sense.

I never said get rid of them, if you have 1 or 2 yellows it should go back to zero each start of season!

At present we have when you get a 3rd yellow you get a red even if you had 2 yellows for 10 seasons! i wonder what the record is, but in my book that should be a medal! ;)
(editado)

but if there would be reset per season or even two seasons will red from 3 yellows ever happen? probably yes, but I think it will less frequent than divine junior, especially taking into account that seasons will be shorter

so I would say we should leave it as it is

I think no. If we remove cards, injuries, randomness... this game would be really boring and predictable
and probably much easier

I suggest no reset BUT a separation for each play system.
Red card for cup should not ban player for league match and vice versa!
Also a yellow card for league and a yellow card for the cup should not be 2 yellow cards for both systems, but 2 times 1 card.

fair point, but if leagues are bigger say 12 in each, 1.9 seasons would be a long time to carry 2 yellows so i say a slight adjustment still needed
i like the fact you can loose a red on cup match so dosnt hurt league but again that's a fair point and i'd have to agree with Dtox9

Red card for cup should not ban player for league match and vice versa!


I think this is a general rule in each country with rl foorball. So I think this should also be the case in Sokker, so as it is right now.