Asunto: Coach Evaluation

Ok I'm going to try something, not sure it'll work as it requires participation.
Over the last season I've spoken with Nothis about optimising the training of English clubs and trying to make sure you've got the best setup you can have, but I wasn't sure how to go about it. Now I have an idea.

The sum of your head coach skills (not including Stamina or Keeping)
Your youth coach level (x6)
The sum of your assistants (x2)

By my math each of those should have a Maximum score of 96, for a combined total of 288 points.

I'll do mine to get it started.

Head coach 94
Youth coach 90
Assistants 70
Total score 254/288

Let's be 'aving you!

Thamesmead 282
Chuck Norris 282
RTS 277
Anfield 275
Padstow 275
Inter Row Z 269
Rock Bottom 268
Eudaimonia 254
Newport 240
(editado)

Think i've done the maths right..

Head Coach 95
Youth Coach 90
Assistants 84 (Made up of 3x Brilliant)
Total Score = 269

Looks good to me. People will always lose points on the assistants but anything over 240 is fairly decent.

Head coach: 95
Youth: 90
Assistants: 90
Total: 275

I suggest the main coach to be calculated on the skills you train. Some users use coaches that are 16 on the skills they train and leave the higher coaches as assistants.
(editado)

That would screw up the calculation. Some would be using 3 skills, others 5.

I could understand only having the skills you need for a head coach but not having that 6x Unearthly is going to cost you big when it comes to positional training.

90 on assistants? Well done.

Head coach: 95
Youth: 96
Assistants: 92
Total: 283


I have a head coach rated at an unearthly level of 95 (excluding Stamina and Keeping), and my academy coach is rated at a magical 96 (excluding the same stats). Which one would you assign as the head coach?
(editado)

Of course, the unearthly trainer has a higher sum skill than the magical one.

Depends on their stamina and whether any of your players needs more stamina.

And what is the magical coach lacking and if you play to train / need to get general training from that skill.
(editado)

If your youth coach is Magical he's a 90 (15x6).
If he's a 96 as a head coach that's what I'd use him as, depending on how much you value stamina and keeping. It seems logical to use the Unearthly as the youth coach.
(editado)

I have a fully maxed Head Coach, Unearthly Youth Coach and 3 x Magical Assistants.

Head Coach - 96
Youth Coach - 96
Assistants - 90
Total - 282
(editado)

I'm getting jealous of all these Magical assistants. I was happy to stop at 3xOutstanding but now I'm wondering.

Head 96 - maxed out with stamina and GK too though
Youth 84
Assistants 88
Total 268

Looks like I'm a cheapskate on youths. No plans to up that though.
(editado)

You can look at it either way really, my coach is better but I shave had nothing decent for seasons so you could argue I have wasted money on him. I am not sure how much difference it makes either, but I do hope soon I will get a few nice youths again....fingers crossed.

Updated everyones scores onto the main post

Here are mine...

Head Coach - 96 (unearthly, 48 yo)
Youth Coach - 96 (unearthly, 43 yo)
Assistant Coach - 96 (magical, 65 yo)
Total = 288

3 Magical assistants would be 90