Asunto: »[Junior]USA Youth Roll Call

now i found another post where someone sais greg said that taller player has slower acceleration but higher chance of winning header.

tbh i have no idea i guess lol

i just looked in polish forum and saw someone write that someone thinks Raul also wrote that height was never implemented.


My tall players happen to perform exceptionally well in the air then. Would love to find out official statement on that.

I found this post

"kryminator to pieniny_88 [del]

Wg mnie w ogóle nie ma znaczenia, ewentualnie ma bardzo małe znaczenie. Ale to tylko moja opinia. Miałem dwumetrowców i nie zauważyłem różnicy pomiędzy nimi a takimi 15-30 cm niższymi."

"
216 / 5,000
kryminator to pieniny_88 [del]

In my opinion it doesn't matter at all, or it does matter very little. But that's just my opinion. I had two-meter tall guys and I didn't notice any difference between them and those 15-30 cm shorter."

My train of thought is - some people read rules and thats where they based their understanding on, which should be the right way.

Then there are things which are either not up to date in rules or were not implemented and someone (raul, greg etc) said so in the forum.

I guess the only way to fix understanding for everyone is to update the rules or find a post by greg or raul etc which states the truth. i am not sure how to search forum to find that post - the search is quite limited afaik

that brings a question, what about height of a goalie :P

"I guess the only way to fix understanding for everyone is to update the rules or find a post by greg or raul etc which states the truth. i am not sure how to search forum to find that post - the search is quite limited afaik"

yes, would be cool to know for sure.

BMI itself was never implemented. I've seen this time and again.

I'm not so sure about the individual components.

Honestly, I was led to believe pace factors into headers. In the sense that if X player gets to the right pass destination first, he'll have a better shot at making contact.

For a goal scorer, striking and tech.

height was implemented long before the new users took over. BMI was left on the self.. unfortunately

So YES it makes a bit difference in headers, and impacts take off speed.

So high BMI doesn’t affect players stamina during match?

So high BMI doesn’t affect players stamina during match?

No.

BMI is such a trash metric for athletes anyway.

General population? Very good.

Finally got lucky week 0. It took 3 seasons to get any 16 yo early. I pulled a 16 yo adequate with 33 weeks left in school. Hopefully talent doesn’t end up 5+. Should have a magical-unearthly 19 yo come out in 5 weeks. Otherwise my YS is trash right now.

Anyone else get lucky this week?

heh i asked Geston today about height and he didnt know so he asked Greg and Greg did not reply:P

whatever is true, this is too much of a detective game for my liking:P

i got 16yo level 3 with 20 weeks left. not sure if lucky or not haha
\what level is adequate?

heh i asked Geston today about height and he didnt know so he asked Greg and Greg did not reply:P

You spying too much

lol it is called research

https://sokker.org/forum_topic/ID_forum/1259/ID_topic/3438030/pg/487 fun thread to read. from what i have read it seems it is not implemented but nothing is 100% for sure. sigh