Asunto: Youth players

Bill Morris - #3 U18 MID

Very nice pull. If you are using Sokker Asistente, definitely worth listing his talent.
If not, you could start using it. just need to log in after training each week, and it will make life a lot easier and quicker
(editado)

How can Isaac munn be 6th u18 mid and Bill morris 3th... when munn have 32 def mid sum and morris 27

I want to buy Isaac munn... can you list european friendly time

Will likely be skills weighted by position and due to passing being low on Munn it’s likely enough to see them slot into a lower position. Ranking can change quickly at the youth end. It’s also likely a point in time reference rather than this player will turn out better in the end.

I ranked seniors using my own weightings and whilst rarer, sometimes certain players ranked higher/lower than what their true spot would be.

I think the point of the ranking is more of a guide or a reference to where the player stands relative to others at the current moment in time. Basically if you had to play someone right now in their current state I’d suspect morris would be chosen over Munn. Doesn’t mean it will be that way by 21 thouuh.

In general IMO at age 16-19 it’s better to follow DEF/MID and ATT sumskill in this kind of ranking, possibly with 1.25x importance of pace (huge difference between 0 pace and 6 pace youth)

I will take a look. Maybe I messed something up. I tend to agree with what Borkos said here
(editado)

Had a quick look.
I am just looking at their MID skills and using Defender more as a differentiator between those with the same mid skill sum.

The main reason for this is whilst I love having mids with defender, later on, unless you train defender, their excellent def won't make much of a difference again magical tech players compared to a good def. For absolute stars (ie sutton) this is a very different story as they will end up with very high mid skills and still be able to have very high defender.

So really it's a result of being in small nations more than anything.

Now when it comes to matches, there are times when I play more aggressive mids who have no defender but much better mid skills, and times I play with more of a defensive set of MIDs.

As I say to everyone, take 'rankings' with a grain of salt, because they change every week with pops always happening, and often if a player is kind of in the ballpark, training them properly can normally get them higher up the ranks and even starting as other players get wasted through the years

Pulled as outstanding (~5.1wks/pop)
Brendan Peake, age: 20
club: The Comets, country: Australia
value : 157 200 AU$ wage: 2 160 AU$
very good [9] form tragic [0] tactical discipline
height: 169 cm, weight: 62.5 kg, BMI: 21.88

weak [4] stamina hopeless [1] keeper
weak [4] pace tragic [0] defender
solid [8] technique solid [8] playmaker
very good [9] passing unsatisfactory [2] striker

Meh younger age perhaps this wouldn't have been too bad.

------------------------------------------------------------------
Pulled as very good (~5.2wks/pop)
Oliver Whincup, age: 19
club: The Comets, country: Australia
value : 91 200 AU$ wage: 1 440 AU$
very good [9] form tragic [0] tactical discipline
height: 177 cm, weight: 74.8 kg, BMI: 23.88

poor [3] stamina tragic [0] keeper
adequate [6] pace unsatisfactory [2] defender
very good [9] technique weak [4] playmaker
poor [3] passing unsatisfactory [2] striker

Again not a great distribution given the age. Probably another not to see any real future

---------------------------------------------------------
Pulled as excellent (~3.9wks/pop)

Alexander Galea, age: 18
club: The Comets, country: Australia
value : 107 600 AU$ wage: 1 560 AU$
very good [9] form tragic [0] tactical discipline
height: 170 cm, weight: 69.3 kg, BMI: 23.98

hopeless [1] stamina tragic [0] keeper
weak [4] pace hopeless [1] defender
good [7] technique solid [8] playmaker
good [7] passing average [5] striker

If striker had gone to defender or passing to pace that would have been very interesting.
Still with the talent he seems to have could be a handy midfield/winger. I am training pace to mids but I'm not training passing/pm for a while as I've just been through those but it is pretty tempting to keep. It's whether I keep him for pace this season and sell when his pace is higher or not. Will have to think.

Train him in pace. Get him to at least incred

A full season pace with that talent will raise his price from nearly nothing to around a mil i think

I'll list Munn on Mon, ending 8am Wed, unless anyone suggests otherwise.

I think he's worth training. Some pace and a round of randoms would do him good. To me, he's a rounded defender, but could be a DM.

Id definitely check/confirm Galeas talent, looks like a nice pace training prospect. And could turn out to be a decent old-fashioned winger (without defender;)

Pulled as V G, talent ???….yes I know, need to reboot S.A. !!!

Joshua Haugland, age: 20
club: Melbourne Mongrels, country: Australia
value : 83 600 AU$, wage: 1 360 AU$
height: 175 cm, weight: 73.3 kg, BMI: 23.93

poor [3] stamina tragic [0] keeper
weak [4] pace solid [8] defender
tragic [0] technique unsatisfactory [2] playmaker
good [7] passing poor [3] striker

If only passing & tech were other way…

Vaughan Haines, age: 18
club: Achmids Soul, country: Australia
value : 45 600 AU$
wage: 960 AU$
very good [9] form
tragic [0] tactical discipline
height: 180 cm, weight: 74.6 kg, BMI: 23.02

tragic [0] stamina hopeless [1] keeper
average [5] pace hopeless [1] defender
hopeless [1] technique weak [4] playmaker
good [7] passing unsatisfactory [2] striker

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Bobby Milligan, age: 17
club: Achmids Soul, country: Australia
value : 30 800 AU$
wage: 800 AU$
very good [9] form
tragic [0] tactical discipline
height: 173 cm, weight: 70 kg, BMI: 23.39

tragic [0] stamina tragic [0] keeper
average [5] pace tragic [0] defender
unsatisfactory [2] technique unsatisfactory [2] playmaker
poor [3] passing weak [4] striker

Can kick. His talent is actually 3.9, so a bit of a shame about his distro.

Jobe Bingley, age: 18, height: 181 cm
value: 64 800 AU$, wage: 1 160 AU$

stamina [3] poor, keeper [0] tragic
pace [0] tragic, defender [0] tragic
technique [0] tragic, playmaker [7] good
passing [6] adequate, striker [5] average

Pulled as a Formidable - could have done with his playmaking going elsewhere, but talent is good

Brodie Galan, age: 17
club: Hackney Marshes, country: Australia
value : 138 800 AU$
wage: 1 960 AU$
very good [9] form
tragic [0] tactical discipline
height: 176 cm, weight: 79.3 kg, BMI: 25.6

poor [3] stamina hopeless [1] keeper
weak [4] pace very good [9] defender
weak [4] technique very good [9] playmaker
weak [4] passing hopeless [1] striker